Say what matters, before you look at schools
Do this first. Otherwise the schools you already like decide your weights for you. Mark a deal-breaker only if a low rating would truly rule a school out. Choose at least three factors.
Name the schools
Use schools you could actually attend: admitted, or likely to be. At least two, up to five.
Rate each school, with evidence
1 is weak, 3 is workable, 5 is excellent, for you. Don't know yet? Choose "Not sure yet" and it goes on your list of information to find.
See where each school stands
The score, out of 100, shows how well a school matches what you said matters. Scores within 5 points are effectively tied; let your notes decide.
How the score works
- Each rating counts from 0 (rated 1) to 100 (rated 5). Nice counts once, Important twice, Very important three times. The score is the weighted average.
- A school is scored only when every factor you weighted has a rating.
- A school rated 3 (Workable) on everything scores 50; mostly 4s scores about 75. The gold bar fills to the score; each segment is one factor's share.
- A deal-breaker rated below your minimum moves the school to "Out unless something changes", whatever its score.
- For each runner-up, the board tries raising each rating by one or two points and reports the smallest change that would put it in front.
Decide, and write down why
The score is a starting point. These questions are where the decision gets made.
Check the money with official numbers
- Cost: each school's own net price calculator for an estimate, then the actual financial aid offer for the final comparison.
- Outcomes and typical cost: College Scorecard (opens in a new tab), U.S. Department of Education.
- Aid and FAFSA deadlines: studentaid.gov (opens in a new tab). School, state and federal deadlines can differ; use the earliest one that applies.
- Accreditation: confirm a recognized agency accredits the school. You can look it up in the Department of Education's accreditation database (opens in a new tab). The Department itself does not accredit schools.
My decision, in one sentence
Keep a backup of your board
Your board lives only in this browser. Save a backup code to move it to another device, share it with a parent or counselor, or keep it safe before clearing your browser.
Restoring replaces the board on this page. You can undo it right after.
Fit is half the decision. The money is the other half.
Deposits, aid forms, housing, orientation: the weeks after you choose are full of small commitments. These Marxman Way tools help you follow through.